Empowering Consumers: A Review of Point-of-Sale POS Financing Products for Retailers

In the dynamic world of retail, Point-of-Sale (POS) financing, a type of embedded lending, is proving to be a game-changer. Its rapid growth mirrors shifting consumer needs and reflects the changing landscape of the retail industry. According to Future Market Insights (FMI), the embedded lending market, including POS financing, will exceed $32.5 billion by 2023 due to the rapid adoption rate of fintech solutions.

Traditional credit card usage is significantly slowing as younger consumers seek more flexible and accessible alternatives. Unlike the conventional one-size-fits-all approach of credit cards, POS financing platforms offer tailored solutions that cater to the unique needs of different customer segments. The result? A shift towards more versatile financing methods, particularly among younger and underserved shoppers.

Embedded finance solutions come in various forms, each with its unique benefits. From revolving lines of credit that offer a set borrowing limit that businesses can repeatedly tap into to the allure of 0% APR programs that promise zero interest for an introductory period, these POS financing options are as diverse as they are flexible.

Furthermore, Buy Now Pay Later (BNPL) programs have emerged as a popular short-term installment solution. Offering an easy-to-understand structure, BNPL allows consumers to purchase goods immediately and pay for them over time, making the entire process hassle-free. Similarly, the lease-to-own concept has found favor, particularly for subprime borrowers seeking to purchase high-priced items such as appliances, furniture, and electronics.

Types of Retailers Using POS Financing

Retailers in many verticals are adopting POS financing and making it a strategic priority given its flexibility and conveniences. As inflation continues to impact customers, demand for POS financing is rising. According to ChargeAfter data, demand for point-of-sale financing increased by 55% in the first quarter of 2023, compared to the same period in 2022. Retailers benefit from offering a robust POS financing experience that meets the needs of all of their customers, especially those selling big-ticket goods or services that are purchased infrequently. In 2023 retailers that are prioritizing upgrading their POS financing offers include:

E-commerce Stores

Online retailers often use POS financing as it can easily be integrated into their checkout process. This allows consumers to choose a financing option at the point of purchase. However, it’s important for many retailers to offer an omnichannel financing experience. 

Electronics Stores

Given the high price of many electronic items such as televisions, laptops, and smartphones, electronics retailers often offer POS financing to make these purchases more affordable for consumers. Customers need to be able to access financing both in-store and online, depending on how they prefer to shop. Additionally, as many electronic retailers serve businesses, they also need to consider B2B financing in their POS offer.

Furniture Stores

Similar to electronics retailers, furniture stores often sell high-ticket items that can be out of reach to many. POS financing can help increase sales and average order value by making these items more accessible to consumers. Retailers need to consider offering an omnichannel financing experience including pre-approval online before visiting a store. They also benefit from offering financing options that cover a range of customers according to different credit scores. 

Home Improvement Stores

Stores that sell appliances or home improvement goods like hardware and construction materials often use POS financing. These items can range in price and financing allows consumers to make these necessary purchases more manageable.

Healthcare Providers

Healthcare and beauty business provide elective surgeries and other costly procedures. They make their treatments accessible to more people when they offer POS financing. By offering POS financing, healthcare providers democratize services that were previously out of reach to many. 

Automotive Dealerships

Dealerships often use POS financing when selling and repairing cars. They may offer financing options, from traditional auto loans to lease-to-own options.

Jewelry Stores

Given the high price of jewelry, these retailers often offer POS financing to make purchases more feasible for consumers.

Types of POS Financing Products

By offering different types of financing products at the point of sale, retailers  meet the needs of more customers.

Revolving Credit Line

A revolving line of credit is a flexible loan arrangement between a financial institution and a customer that establishes a maximum loan balance that the lender permits the borrower. It allows the borrower to use funds up to a set limit and repay them, potentially over and over again. Unlike a traditional loan, where the borrower receives a lump sum upfront and starts paying it back in installments, a revolving line of credit lets the borrower withdraw funds up to the set limit as needed. Interest is charged only on the borrowed amount, not the entire credit limit. Once the borrower repays any portion of the borrowed amount, that portion becomes available again for future use. This “revolving” structure gives the borrower the flexibility to manage their borrowing and repayment schedules within the agreed terms. A typical example of a revolving line of credit is a credit card, where the cardholder can spend up to a specific limit, repay the balance, and then spend again.

Long-Term Installment Loans

Long-term installment loans are loans that borrowers repay over a set number of scheduled payments or installments over an extended period. Depending on the loan agreement, this period can range from several months to several years. Long-term installment loans can be secured or unsecured. Secured loans require collateral, such as a house or a car, and typically have lower interest rates because the lender can seize the collateral if the borrower defaults. Unsecured loans, which are provided at the point of sale, do not require collateral but usually have higher interest rates to compensate for the increased risk to the lender.

The terms of long-term installment loans, including the loan amount, interest rate, and repayment schedule, are typically determined at the outset and spelled out in the loan agreement. Each installment payment reduces the principal amount owed and covers the interest on the debt, making these loans easier to budget for than revolving credit lines, where the minimum payment can vary. Long-term installment loans are often used for major purchases or investments, such as buying a house (mortgage), buying a car (auto loan), or funding higher education (student loan). They provide borrowers with the means to afford big-ticket items and significant expenses they couldn’t cover upfront, spreading the cost over an extended period.

0% APR

0% Annual Percentage Rate (APR) refers to a promotional interest rate offered by lenders where no interest is charged on the principal amount for a specified period. This period can range from a few months to a few years, depending on the terms set by the lender. Often seen in credit cards or auto financing, this offer allows borrowers to finance purchases or transfer balances from high-interest accounts without accruing additional interest during the promotional period.

It’s important to note, however, that once the promotional period ends, any remaining balance starts to accrue interest at the regular rate as defined in the terms of the agreement. Moreover, 0% APR offers usually require the borrower to have good to excellent credit, and the terms may stipulate that if a payment is missed or late, the promotional rate ends prematurely, and a higher interest rate applies. It’s, therefore, crucial to understand the terms and conditions attached to a 0% APR offer before proceeding.

Buy Now Pay Later (BNPL)

BNPL, or Buy Now, Pay Later, is a type of short-term installment financing that allows consumers to purchase goods or services immediately and pay for them over time. Typically, payments are made in fixed installments over a set period, such as weeks or months. One of the main attractions of BNPL for consumers is that, in many cases, these payment plans do not incur high interest or fees, provided payments are made on time. Some BNPL services offer 0% interest financing if the balance is paid within a specified promotional period. This can make BNPL more affordable than traditional credit cards for some consumers, particularly for more expensive purchases.

Consumers need to understand the terms of their BNPL agreement. Late fees may apply if payments are not made on time, and interest may be charged on the remaining balance. In some cases, if the balance is not paid off by the end of the promotional period, interest may be charged retroactively from the purchase date.

BNPL has seen a surge in popularity in recent years, particularly among younger consumers, and is now offered by a wide range of online and physical retailers. Typically BNPL is used for small-ticket items with a value of between $50 and $1000 (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau). Based on five surveyed lenders from 2019 to 2021, BNPL loans grew by 970%, from 16.8 to 180 million. The dollar volume grew by 109%, from $2 billion to $24.2 billion.(Consumer Financial Protection Bureau). 

Lease To Own

“Lease to own”, also known as “rent to own”, is a type of agreement that allows a customer to lease a product with the option to purchase it at the end of the lease term. This financing option is typically used for expensive furniture, appliances, vehicles, and electronics for subprime customers. The customer makes regular payments over a specified period in a lease-to-own agreement. These payments contribute toward the total purchase price of the product. At the end of the lease term, the customer can buy the item for either a small residual amount or the sum of the remaining unpaid purchase price.

The advantage of a lease-to-own agreement for customers is that it allows them to use and enjoy an item immediately without paying the total purchase price upfront. It can benefit those who cannot afford high-cost items or do not qualify for traditional financing. However, it’s worth noting that the total cost paid over the lease term can be higher than the item’s original price due to the inclusion of interest and fees. Therefore, customers should carefully review the terms of a lease-to-own agreement before proceeding.

B2B Financing

B2B POS Financing (point-of-sale financing), is allows businesses to finance purchases at the point of sale, the same way consumers do. This type of financing is often used for purchases of larger quantities of goods or services since businesses typically purchase in bulk to meet operational needs, inventory requirements, or to fulfill contracts with their own customers.  Most merchants provide their own b2b financing, usually with offers with 30, 60, or 90-day payback.  These terms are not favorable for many businesses, especially SMBs, and new providers are coming into the market offering business loans with expanded terms. These new POS financing options offer immediate approval (or denial) of credit at the point of sale, making the purchasing process quicker and smoother and resulting in higher approval rates. The buyer can repay the amount over time per the terms of the financing agreement, which can be up to 12 months, giving businesses greater flexibility. B2B POS financing can benefit both the buyer and the seller. For the buyer, it provides immediate access to needed goods or services without a significant upfront investment. For the seller, it can facilitate significant sales, increase cash flow, and foster stronger customer relationships.

 

Challenges of Single-Lender POS Financing

While the benefits of POS financing are manifold, relying on a single lender can be limiting. Single-lender solutions can lead to lower approval rates and a poor customer journey. Declined shoppers start the POS financing process again, resulting in cart abandonment, and affecting sales and customer loyalty. There is also the risk of being subject to the changing lending conditions of a single financial institution.

Why Retailers Must Start With Embedded POS Financing Platforms First

Many retailers are turning towards embedded finance platforms that offer many lending options through a single gateway to counter these challenges. With an embedded lending network, retailers can manage multiple financing options like BNPL, installment loans, and lease-to-own, providing an omnichannel financing experience.

Indeed, research by ChargeAfter suggests that 66% of retailers prioritize implementing a consumer financing platform that manages the entire financing cycle, including reconciliations, chargebacks, and dispute resolution.

An embedded finance platform also removes the burden of managing complex requirements from the retailers, facilitating seamless management of waterfall financing, in which applications are automatically sent to lenders in a sequence until approval is obtained.

Merchants are thus looking for point-of-sale financing platforms that offer white-label consumer financing solutions and BNPL white-label options, giving them control over the customer experience while handling the complexity of lending and compliance in the background.

 

Conclusion

As retailers adapt to the evolving needs of their customers, it’s clear that the future lies in leveraging robust POS financing platforms. Offering an omnichannel lending experience through an embedded lending platform can significantly enhance the shopping experience, increase approval rates, and boost sales, making it a win-win for consumers and retailers.

Through white-label POS systems and a waterfall finance approach, retailers offer consumers the flexibility they desire and a better experience.

Retailers that adapt to these changes and invest in POS financing solutions today will undoubtedly be better positioned to cater

To the needs of the next-generation consumer, we are leading the way in the ever-evolving world of retail.

With embedded financing becoming increasingly popular, it’s time to embrace this trend and reap the benefits of enhanced customer satisfaction and increased sales. After all, in retail, customer experience is king – and an omnichannel financing experience through a robust POS financing platform is a significant step in that direction.

Boost Your Sales Growth: The Benefits of Ecommerce Financing

Consumer finance is not set to grow. It’s growing!

According to data from the Federal Reserve, (POS) Point-of-sale financing makes up approximately 10% of the total unsecured lending balances in the United States. In 2020, credit card balances amounted to around $750 billion, while POS balances totaled about $100 billion. Nevertheless, POS financing is expanding more rapidly than any other category of unsecured lending. It is set to grow at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 20% for the 5 years preceding 2024. (I.e. financial years 2020 up to and including 2024)

Consumer Finance market growth

Similarly, according to McKinsey Consumer Lending Pools, the same trend is can be seen internationally with POS financing making up 11%

growth of point of sale financing pos financing

 

Prudence Research has also shown, how BNPL, a financial instrument for short term installment loans,  falling within the POS Finance umbrella, has grown and how it is forecasted to grow dramatically in the coming years.

For instance, the Buy Now Pay Later market size is forecasted to grow to a staggering 3.2 Trillion dollars by 2030.

buy now pay later market size

Financing can expand the customer base for various purchases, including appliances, electronics,  furniture, home improvement projects, and services like elective medical procedures and dental equipment and procedures. Offering financing options can boost sales for any seller, whether in a brick-and-mortar store, online, or through a call center, and cater to all consumer types.

Buying a product or service that costs between $1,000 and $10,000 is more complex than making a $50 purchase by swiping your credit card. Businesses need to make an effort to attract a broader range of consumers.

Through embedded finance, consumer financing has expanded beyond buy now, pay later and adopted long-term installment payment, 0% APR, revolving lines of credit, and more, to offer consumers flexible payment options.

Industry analysis found how consumer financing increases merchant sales. For instance:

  • According to The Inaugural Citizens Point of Sale Survey by Citizens Financial Group, the most notable finding is that 76% of consumers are more likely to make big-ticket sales when given the option of consumer financing, such as BNPL or other payment plan options.Of those surveyed, 66% want consumer finance alternatives to credit cards.The survey revealed that consumers would prefer non-credit-card consumer financing with fixed monthly plans,  clear payment terms, and a clear understanding of how the amount will be paid off as the most important factors when considering a large purchase.

 

  • Comparably, a study by Futurepay.com reports that 56% of shoppers are more inclined to purchase a high-priced item online if financing options are available. This percentage increases to 73% for frequent online shoppers. These statistics are very close to findings by the Citizens Financial Group.

    shoppers using layaway & consumer finance on big ticket items
  • A recent FREE retailer insights survey by ChargeAfter indicates that from a retailer’s perspective, 85% of retailers expect year-on-year growth in consumer financing.

 

Consumer Finance: Higher Value, More Sales


Merchants selling higher ticket items who offer consumer finance options achieve more sales than merchants without consumer financing options.

‘The Big Ticket: What’s stopping Shoppers’ (big-ticket survey) published its findings.

According to them, financing alternatives stimulate high-value purchases. Over two-thirds of shoppers (68%) and 79% of daily shoppers would be more inclined to purchase a high-priced item if they could divide the cost into smaller payments. For high-priced items under $1,000, almost half of all shoppers (47%) prefer alternative financing over a credit card to complete the transaction. Even at a price as low as $200, 15% of shoppers were willing to switch away from a credit card.

price point when shoppers use consumer finance**

 

Similarly, ChargeAfters’ Retailer survey released in 2023, from a retailers’ perspective, states that merchants recognize that financing options drive big-ticket purchases.

The number of BNPLs merchants offered to customers is not affected by the retailers Average Order Value (AOV). However, other POS financing options vary significantly depending on the AOV of the business. When the AOV is less than $500, companies typically offer 2.5 different POS financing options. However, when the retailer AOV exceeds $500, this number increases to 3.5 different POS financing options. As their AOV increases, merchants seek to diversify their payment options to meet customer demands. There is no one-size-fits-all solution regarding financing options, particularly with a substantial AOV. Offering a limited BNPL of pay in four or six installments is insufficient as customers require more flexibility and choice.


Financing options by Average Order Value (AOV)

Financing options by Average Order Value AOV

Fintech companies at the forefront of consumer finance innovation offer embedded financing & lending technologies making it easier for merchants to integrate omnichannel consumer financing solutions.
Embedded finance solutions that integrate easily, such as ChargeAfters’ multi-lender platform, allows merchants to offer their customers quick, convenient, and personalized financing options.

Customers connect to a wide choice of financial products and lenders in a single application, resulting in an 85% approval rate. Merchants increase sales by offering consumer financing and installment payments on sales where the same customers would typically walk away from the sale.

 

Reduce Cart Abandonment with Consumer Finance


The Big Ticket: What’s stopping Shoppers survey found that 66% of shoppers abandon their carts after adding an item to their shopping cart.
72% of this abandonment was due to the items being too expensive, and 16% because there were no payment options.

shopping cart abandonment reasons

 

 

Another Research conducted by beymard.com in 2022 shows that site trust (18%), complicated checkout process (17%), inability to calculate total order cost upfront (16%), not enough payment options (9%) and. Credit card declines (4%) are the main reasons for abandonment. These statistics can be significantly improved with the correct embedded finance technology.

reason for shopping cart abandonments during checkout

With an embedded lending platform like that of ChargeAfter, merchants can increase sales by decreasing cart abandonment.

Conclusion

 

Reducing cart abandonment is one of the most significant benefits of offering consumer financing and installment payments in e-commerce stores. Many customers abandon their carts because they need help to afford the full price of an item at the time of purchase. However, by offering financing options, merchants can make sales more affordable and accessible, reducing the likelihood of cart abandonment and increasing the chances of a sale.

In addition to reducing cart abandonment, offering financing options can increase customer loyalty and repeat business. Customers who take advantage of financing options are more likely to return to the same merchant for future purchases, as they have established a relationship and trust with the merchant through the financing process.

Offering financing options can help merchants reach a wider audience of potential customers. Many consumers who may not have been able to afford high-ticket items in the past may now be able to do so with financing options, opening up a whole new market for the merchant.

Finally, offering financing options can help merchants stand out from the competition and differentiate themselves in the crowded e-commerce marketplace. By providing financing options, merchants can provide a more comprehensive and customer-centric shopping experience that distinguishes them from other retailers.

Unleash the Power of Embedded Finance: Here Are Some Use Cases

Introduction

Embedded finance is a growing trend in the finance industry that involves integrating financial services into non-financial customer journeys, and it is now becoming prevalent in both B2C and B2B contexts. Embedded finance options will eventually be the norm for B2C purchases, even for traditionally conducted offline transactions. This trend helps to increase customer engagement and loyalty. As this trend continues to grow, many industries are exploring various embedded finance use cases.

Embedded Finance Forecast

 

 

What is Embedded Finance?

Embedded finance allows non-financial companies to integrate financial services or products into their digital offerings, making it more convenient for customers to purchase products and streamlining business processes. This trend has also led to embedded fintech, wherein financial service platforms integrate into commercial or financial service platforms.

In short, an embedded finance ecosystem integrates the various spheres necessary to complete the entire cycle of a financed transaction.

For instance, when a retail customer makes a purchase (in-store or online) and opts to pay for the purchase in installments, three things need to exist;

The Seller – The merchant selling the product or services through the systems they employ. In this case their Point-Of-Sale system.
In embedded finance, this is the ‘Distributor’ or ‘Embedder.’
These are retailers, software companies, and marketplaces – that integrate financial services into their products to benefit their customers.

 

The Lender – providing finance for the product or services purchased in point #1 for a fee and/or interest, allowing the seller to sell a product with no financial risk.
However, sometimes the ‘lender’ role is also fulfilled by the seller as a second source of revenue by offering loans with interest.
This is the ‘Balance Sheet Provider’ or ‘Financial service provider’: Banks, fintech, and other financial institutions.

And

Technology Provider – configuring and integrating the systems between the seller system and the lender system to create and maintain a seamless transaction
The ‘Technology Provider’ or ‘embedded financing platforms‘ are both experts in the seller technologies and service design and well-versed in the regulations and intricacies of providing financial services. They help stitch the embedded finance ecosystem together. They look at the customer journey to provide processes that are simplified and personalized.

 

A real world example would be Point of Sales financing whereby:

  • The retailer would be the ‘Seller’ such as Lenovo

 

Lenovo consumer finance bnpl

 

  • The ‘Balance Sheet Provider’ would be a group of lenders bidding to offer the best consumer financing deal (long term installments financing)

 

  • The ‘Technology Provider’, such as ChargeAfter’, enables this transaction to occur by integrating and connecting ‘The seller’ with ‘the balance sheet provider’ in an automated manner, facilitating the transaction efficiently.

Lenovo consumer finance bnpl

 

 

Types of Embedded Finance

types of consumer finance - embedded finance

* Embedded finance, a multi-trillion dollar opportunity, Source: The rise of embedded finance, Dealroom and ABN AMRO Ventures, 2022

 

  • Embedded Lending and Buy Now Pay Later (BNPL)

 

BNPL is an example of embedded lending. It falls under Point of Sale financing (also known as POS financing). BNPL  is a lending option that allows customers to purchase goods or services and pay for them through short term installment loans. BNPL financing is usually offered by fintech companies.

Point-of-sale (POS) financing is an umbrella term that describes a variety of embedded lending  methods and products. These include BNPL but also pay over time for longer and bigger purchases, as well as 0% APR, revolving line of credit, lease-to-own, and more.

Point-of-sale loans like these are gaining popularity and have become essential in improving the user experience and driving customer loyalty through repeat purchases.
According to a 2022 article by The Ascent, 56% of consumers surveyed in 2021 have used a buy now, pay later service, this is up from 37% in July 2020*

* https://www.fool.com/the-ascent/research/buy-now-pay-later-statistics/

 

Increasingly, Point-of-sale loans are integrated with online e-commerce websites as well as in-store.
Well-known big retail brands such as Best Buy, Costco,, Target, Walmart, and countless others recognize the value in offering various embedded consumer finance options in their online channels and stores with an omnichannel experience. Many of these big brands opt to integrate with consumer financing platforms such as ChargeAfter instead of developing their own.

ChargeAfter’s omnichannel multi-lender platform is designed to support merchants by providing various financing options to consumers and businesses. The platform is pre-integrated with more than 30 leading lenders, enabling merchants to offer multiple financing options using a single application directly on their e-commerce website or retail location. The platform allows for a quick financing approval process, with up to 85% of financing approvals completed in less than three seconds.

ChargeAfter’s embedded  financing platform is designed to offer shoppers various financing options, regardless of their credit history. The platform offers 0% APR, open lines of credit, short and long-term installments, card installments, lease-to-own, and B2B financing options.

 

There are many examples of well-known retail brands that offer embedded financing and BNPL at the point of sale. Below are some examples:

Jerome’s Furniture:

showcases its financing options already at the homepage, allowing customers to prequalify for financing offers.

 

Jeromes consumer finance bnpl embedded finance

 

 

In addition they embed the financing offer within the PDP:

 

Jeromes consumer finance bnpl embedded finance

 

42photo.com

Presents a promo pop up with the financial offer – welcoming any customer to to choose business financing

 

42photo.com consumer finance bnpl embedded finance

embedding the Point of Sale financing as part of a seamless checkout process:

42photo.com consumer finance bnpl embedded finance

 

 

Digital Wallets Integrated into Mobile or Online Platforms

 

Digital wallets allow customers to store and use digital currency to make payments or transfers, manage their financial accounts and track their spending. They can also be linked to traditional bank accounts or credit cards, providing a seamless and convenient way to make transactions. Examples of digital wallets include Apple Pay and Google Wallet.

  • Some of Apple’s partners, to name but a few, include Best Buy, Disney, Dunkin Donuts, McDonald’s, Walgreens, Costco, Target, and Taco Bell.

 

Apple best buy consumer finance bnpl embedded finance

 

 

  • Google Pay also facilitates payment with Best Buy and other distributors.

 

Google pay bestbuy.com consumer finance embedded finance

 

  • Loyalty programs with digital or store credit rewardsLoyalty programs that offer rewards or cashback in the form of digital currency or store credit allow customers to earn and use rewards or cashback within the platform or service they are already using. For example, credit card companies or retailers may offer rewards or cashback through loyalty points redeemed for discounts or other benefits.A familiar example of a loyalty program is the Star Bucks Rewards.

 

starbucks.com rewards consumer finance embedded finance

 

Conclusion

Embedded finance has arrived and is making its way into the finance ecosystem. The trend will continue to grow throughout all verticals of business and service providers, and more industries will adapt to it. By integrating financial services or products into their platforms, merchants  can offer a more seamless customer experience while streamlining their back-end processes. With the advent of omnichannel lending, including POS financing and BNPL, the future of B2C and B2B financing at the point of sales looks bright.

MAG 2023 Mid-Year Conference and Tech Forum

The Annual Conference and Tech Forum for Merchant Advisory Group (MAG) will take place from 13 Feb to 16 Feb 2023 at the J.W. Marriott San Antonio Hill Country Resort & Spa, Texas.

J.W. Marriott San Antonio Hill Country Resort & Spa, Texas

Visit Mark, Mike and Jim at our booth and listen to our experts speak about some of the most recent consumer finance developments, such as omnichannel, embedded finance and consumer experience.

The event is two and a half days of consumer financing.

Make connections with the best networks, acquirers, and senior-level payments executives from the best merchants. In addition to the networking event, there will be the merchant only Special Interest Group (SIG) talks.

 

The 2023 Mid-Year Conference Tech Forum will delve into the technology of payments and bring together merchant IT professionals and their business partners with technology sponsors through informative sessions and networking events.

The conference offers retailers and sponsors the opportunity to network in person and to learn about the latest developments in the payments industry. There will be unique networking opportunities available for conference participants to engage in.

The distinctive experience provided by MAG Conferences draws both payments experts of embedded finance and individuals who oversee organizational tasks that include consumer payments and associated challenges.

 

Connect with merchant technology experts and top technology suppliers focused on emerging payment technologies. Payment technologies are continuously evolving with innovations in embedded finance such as buy-now-pay-later (BNPL) POS financing, and other consumer financing technologies.